It is my experience and my observation that when it comes to doing worship - and being church - differently, a lot of the resistance comes down to a simple and horrible case of classism. And I just can't figure out why we're not dealing with this. We seem willing enough to at least talk about our racism, our sexism, and the various issues we have around sexual orientation. But we aren't talking about why we don't have the NASCAR crowd at worship on Sunday morning. And, since NASCAR is like the most watched sport in the country, this might explain why we have such a hard time reaching ANYBODY outside our walls including, by the way, our own kids (who are, of course, the biggest consumers of Reality TV).
Frankly, I think most of the people INSIDE our walls would secretly like to see things be different (i.e. a little "Reality Worship," perhaps?!?) but they think they have to dress up & "worship UP" to be a part of our churches. In other words, while we long ago stopped telling non-Western people that they have to act Western in order to be Christian, we are still telling working class/blue collar/proletariat people that they have to act snooty (for example, listen to classical music for at least one hour a week and look like you're enjoying it...if you're in a traditional church, that is...listen to jazz and wear your best torn up jeans...if you're in an emerging one) to be members of our churches.
I don't think anybody explains better than Martin Luther why it's important for worship to be deeply contextual (see the article below about his Preface to the German Mass)...but all that theology aside...I just think it sucks that we treat people so poorly.
Sorry if I appear to be meddling where I don't belong. I'll just slink away and pop in my DVD of "Talladega Nights." That'll keep me laughing...and out of your hair for awhile.
Showing posts with label contemporary worship. Show all posts
Showing posts with label contemporary worship. Show all posts
Thursday, May 10, 2007
Now She's Meddling
"The Atlantic" is not exactly Proletariat reading material. It's not, for example, sitting on the table in the grimy waiting room of your local car repair shop or in the magazine rack at your local beauty parlor. At least not the ones in my neighborhood. This is a magazine with articles about "Stalin on the Eastern Front" and "A Safari by air over Namibia's haunting sand" and "Why we should worry about the military's increased political assertiveness" and "Freeloading aesthetes and the women who kept them." There's a whole section on POETRY every month, ok? Enough said.
But in this month's issue there is a fascinating article praising, against all odds, the virtues of Reality TV. Nothing is easier to make fun of. Mention it at your next social gathering and watch people turn their noses up, as though somebody in the room just had the audacity to fart in public. No one with any CLASS would admit that they're a fan - and I mean a real fan, not an embarrassed "I-can't-believe-I-watch-it-either-I-just-can't-help-myself" fan - but a real FAN who really CARES about whether or not LaKisha Jones will have a career after getting booted off Idol before her time (Blake survived?!? Puh-lease!!) and whether or not she'll be able to support her little girl, struggling single mom that she is. [If you missed it live(!), you can catch up at http://www.chicagotribune.com/entertainment/sns-ap-tv-american-idol,1,7040377.story?coll=chi-entertainmentfront-hed]
Reality TV is a sign of America's demise, right? The end times have to be near! And the 45 million people who voted for this week's Idol are barbarians who are responsible for the decline of our civilization. God help us all.
But this author, convincingly!, argues that nothing on TV today takes more risks or is more vibrant. "Real Housewives," he says, charts the spiritual decay of life in gated communities where financial anxieties, fraying families, fear of aging (and, we can surmise, the absence of sidewalks) leaves people grasping for meaning and happiness. "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition" captures the stories of real people who have fallen through the cracks in the Bush era, ravaged by health-care crises and layoffs. There is no predictability in Reality TV, no assurance that, in the end, lessons will be learned and order restored. What's more, says the author, "Narrative vibrancy is not the only thing that electrifies these shows. Reality TV presents some of the most vital political debate in America, particularly about class and race."
The author, Michael Hirschorn, makes his living producing Reality TV shows and so you might expect him to have a biased opinion. But he's right that no one is even bothering to look for the good in these shows. They just roll their eyes. And I've got to admit, I was almost cheering when he finally made his point that the only reason anybody is picking on Reality TV is because they are snobs.
Now maybe I was so taken by Hirschorn's willingness to name the ugly classist attitudes that run like poison through the crowds I travel in because, although my car radio is tuned to NPR, my vehicle of choice is a pick up truck. And I happen to have my most meaningful worship experiences when there is a good drummer driving the beat. And I feel uncomfortable when the preacher uses that "God" voice and insists on using words that have more than three syllables or sound like Greek to me (because they actually ARE Greek). And it makes me a little nuts when the worship leaders are prancing around in robes that were originally designed to keep priests warm in the unheated cathedrals of Northern Europe but now form the basis of a Sunday morning pageant, instead of just dressing and sounding and acting like normal people. And I really LIKE it when there's a projector and screen in the sanctuary, especially if it's being used to show movie clips or photos that illustrate the point of the sermon and communcate the good news and make the Biblical stories come alive. Maybe I was cheering for Hirschorn because my dad was a mill rat - a factory worker - and I was so incredibly offended to learn that one of my colleagues, when I was a member of a seminary faculty, told his students that lay worship assistants (whose main job is to read prayers the pastor writes out for them and hold the book so the pastor can make just the right hand motions at just the right time) can jokingly be referred to as "blue collar clerics." Another colleague taught his students that guitars have no place in worship because "all guitars make people think about is sex." I'm so not kidding.
It is my experience and my observation that when it comes to doing worship - and being church - differently, a lot of the resistance comes down to a simple and horrible case of classism. And I just can't figure out why we're not dealing with this. We seem willing enough to at least talk about our racism, our sexism, and the various issues we have around sexual orientation. But we aren't talking about why we don't have the NASCAR crowd at worship on Sunday morning. And, since NASCAR is like the most watched sport in the country, this might explain why we have such a hard time reaching ANYBODY outside our walls including, by the way, our own kids (who are, of course, the biggest consumers of Reality TV).
Frankly, I think most of the people INSIDE our walls would secretly like to see things be different (i.e. a little "Reality Worship," perhaps?!?) but they think they have to dress up & "worship UP" to be a part of our churches. In other words, while we long ago stopped telling non-Western people that they have to act Western in order to be Christian, we are still telling working class/blue collar/proletariat people that they have to act snooty (for example, listen to classical music for at least one hour a week and look like you're enjoying it...if you're in a traditional church, that is...listen to jazz and wear your best torn up jeans...if you're in an emerging one) to be members of our churches.
I don't think anybody explains better than Martin Luther why it's important for worship to be deeply contextual (see the article below about his Preface to the German Mass)...but all that theology aside...I just think it sucks that we treat people so poorly.
Sorry if I appear to be meddling where I don't belong. I'll just slink away and pop in my DVD of "Talladega Nights." That'll keep me laughing...and out of your hair for awhile.
It is my experience and my observation that when it comes to doing worship - and being church - differently, a lot of the resistance comes down to a simple and horrible case of classism. And I just can't figure out why we're not dealing with this. We seem willing enough to at least talk about our racism, our sexism, and the various issues we have around sexual orientation. But we aren't talking about why we don't have the NASCAR crowd at worship on Sunday morning. And, since NASCAR is like the most watched sport in the country, this might explain why we have such a hard time reaching ANYBODY outside our walls including, by the way, our own kids (who are, of course, the biggest consumers of Reality TV).
Frankly, I think most of the people INSIDE our walls would secretly like to see things be different (i.e. a little "Reality Worship," perhaps?!?) but they think they have to dress up & "worship UP" to be a part of our churches. In other words, while we long ago stopped telling non-Western people that they have to act Western in order to be Christian, we are still telling working class/blue collar/proletariat people that they have to act snooty (for example, listen to classical music for at least one hour a week and look like you're enjoying it...if you're in a traditional church, that is...listen to jazz and wear your best torn up jeans...if you're in an emerging one) to be members of our churches.
I don't think anybody explains better than Martin Luther why it's important for worship to be deeply contextual (see the article below about his Preface to the German Mass)...but all that theology aside...I just think it sucks that we treat people so poorly.
Sorry if I appear to be meddling where I don't belong. I'll just slink away and pop in my DVD of "Talladega Nights." That'll keep me laughing...and out of your hair for awhile.
Tuesday, April 10, 2007
Getting Worship Right
I guess I took a few people by surprise with the letter to the editor I contributed to this month's "Lutheran" magazine. I was responding to a lead article in February's issue about WORSHIP that claimed to represent a Lutheran pattern for the "work" of worship. (You can read it yourself at http://www.thelutheran.org/article/article_buy.cfm?article_id=6296.) In fact, this article represents a 20th century liturgical, largly Roman, movement that has inflitrated mainline Protestantism, unknowingly influenced the contemporary Christian praise & worship scene, and I believe threatens to undo the emerging church movement.
I got my undies in a bunch when I read this article, written by a leading and highly repected worship teacher, for several reasons: 1) It acts like the worship debates are over - and that they have been won by the traditionalists, liturgists, and museum curators - nevermind the fact that increasing numbers of Christians are worshiping in all kinds of both new and ancient ways, 2) It tells the story of a little boy who got chased away from the Communion table - without irony, as if not to recognize that our "worship" services (and our congregations) chase people away all the time, and 3) It totally misses the mark in terms of what a confessional, Reformation theology might actually have to offer as we attempt to connect with each other and with the stranger in the midst of this postmodern mission field. Here's what I said:
We have plenty of (really important!) things to argue about within the ELCA (Evangelical Lutheran Church in American) besides worship. But your February issue gives the impression the debate is over. It’s not. In fact, many of us are frustrated by the mid-20th century liturgical movement which has infiltrated Lutheranism, turning worship into “work of the people” rather than (as the Reformers understood it) something God uses to evangelize sinners (i.e., all of us!). We are not “baffled” by the liturgy or afflicted by the need to “create something different.” (Why is that a bad thing, anyway?!) Every congregation in North America sits in the middle of a mission field. If we have thrown away our hymnals, it may be because our first priority is sharing the good news of Jesus within a changing culture. What we desperately need, in order to do that well, is a Lutheran theology of worship that is both deeply confessional and radically missional. This issue offered neither.
You see, I believe those 16th century reformers actually have something to teach us today. Read Martin Luther's Preface to The German Mass and Order of Divine Service, January 1526, and see for yourself. Here are a few of the key things I hear the old man saying:
1. I don't want to write a new order for worship because I'm afraid everyone will think they have to do it this way forever...and they most definitely don't. "No order has any intrinsic worth of its own..." (Luther)
2. The "Divine Service" (he does not use the word "worship") is designed within the context of Christian freedom. In other words, we are free from all legalistic orders and traditions in every part of our life together, and bound by one thing only: Service to our neighbor.
3. What does our neighbor need? The good news that Jesus came to bring, about the inbreaking reign of God! The POINT of all our forms and orders (including the "Divine Service") is this, Luther says: "the promotion of faith and the service of love" (Luther). In other words, the purpose of the Service is to teach and equip us - sinners all, and especially the simple, unbelievers, and the young - to be a part of God's mission in the world! One radical conclusion: The OBJECT of our "worship" service is not God! God is the SUBJECT of the service. WE, the people who are participating in the service, are the objects. The message, the singing, the readings, everything is done with US in mind -to teach us and equip us.
4. Finally, Luther recommends three different forms or orders for the Service.
a. First, keep the Latin mass. Why? Because it will teach us a foreign language and "I would gladly raise up a generation able to be of use to Christ in foreign lands and to talk to their people..." (Luther).
b. Second, offer a Service in German (the native language) for the sake of people "in general" who are "not yet believers or Christians" as a "public allurement to faith and Christianity" (Luther). Don't make them learn your language or customs! Use their language, customs, and means of communication so that they can understand what you are saying!
c. Third, and most radically, Luther describes the "true type of Evangelical Order," the ideal Service, as a HOUSE CHURCH!: "Those, however, who are desirous of being Christians in earnest, and are ready to profess the Gospel with hand and mouth, should register their names and assemble by themselves in some house to pray, to read, to baptize and to receive the sacrament and practise other Christian works...Here there would not be need of much fine singing. Here we could have baptism and the sacrament in short and simple fashion: and direct everything towards the Word and prayer and love."
The bottom line is this: In too many places - traditional, contemporary, and emergent - worship is about what WE do. Whether we're wearing albs or playing the drums or lighting candles and asking deep questions in a coffee shop, we make worship our common "work." But the Reformer teaches us that the Christian service is not OUR work; it is God's. The purpose of the Christian service is NOT to "worship" God, at all. (God doesn't need or want our worship & praise, people! Read Amos 5:21-24 again.) The service is to teach & show us how to be Christians and how to DO the Christian life, as participants in God's mission to love and bless and reconcile and set free and save the world.
So, what questions, if they are taking direction from the Reformer, should worship service PLANNERS today be asking? Here are a couple:
1. Are our words and actions helping people learn (here's a clue: LECTURES DON'T DO THAT!)?!
2. Are we really equipping people to live and share their faith? Where is our evidence?
3. Are our words, images, media communicating in the language of those who do not yet believe and, especially, the young?
4. Who is this service FOR? How is it serving our neighbor? Do we even know who our neighbors are?!? How is it providing for a "public allurement to faith" in this context?
5. The biggest challenge is to the get the DIRECTION of worship right: God's Word comes DOWN to teach, equip, save, and set us free to love & serve our neighbor. If our songs are all about how Jesus is my boyfriend...or we're "working" hard at telling God how wonderful God is in our music and our prayers and our liturgies...or we're navel gazing more often than we're listening for a Word from the living God...we've got the direction mixed up.
It worries me that the traditionalists think they've won, and so many in the contemporary and emergent camps want to show how they really ARE using liturgical forms (just in a new contemporary or ancient-new way), partly so we can all just make nice. Nice is overrated. I think what we need is a rousing conversation - and the Reformers need to be at the table.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
FOLLOW ME TO MY NEW BLOG SITE!
Quick link to my books & web site
- Reclaiming the C Word: Daring to Be Church Again, 2006
- No Experience Necessary: Everybody's Welcome, 2005
- A Story Worth Sharing: Engaging Evangelism, 2004
- Reclaiming the L Word: Renewing the Church From its Lutheran Core, 2003
- Dancing Down the Hallway: Spiritual Reflections for the Everyday, 2001
- No Experience Necessary: The Bible Study (units 1-8), with Rolf Jacobson, 2005-2006
- A.R.E.: A Renewal Enterprise - my web site
The Bottom Line
For you were called to freedom, brothers and sisters; only do not use your freedom as an opportunity for self-indulgence, but through love becomes slaves to one another. For the whole law is summed up in a single commandment, "You shall love your neighbor as yourself." - Galatians 5:13-14